Moral Theology: Its Method and Masters
Leonard Lessius
Drawn from the authors' own words; every quotation links to its place.
S.J. · Jesuit · 1554–1623
On this site:
In the Index: Lessius
His Moral System
Probabilist ("weighty and probabilist", St. Alphonsus's judgment by Haringer's sign **)
- “Lessius Leonardus, Belgian, is to be numbered among the greatest ornaments of the Society of Jesus” — Gury-Ballerini, Haringer's index of writers
What Our Authors Say of Him
- “wrote the very celebrated work De iustitia et iure ceterisque virtutibus cardinalibus” — Prümmer, Catalogue of authors
His Moral System, as Our Authors Report It
Every report quoted in the author's own words and linked to its place; point at a name to see his words. Haringer's signs give St. Alphonsus's judgment as Haringer found it in St. Alphonsus's works (his notice, Gury-Ballerini, 1884, p. XI); a sign on a writer the 1884 editor added to the list is the editor's own, and is said to be his.
| Probabilist | |
|---|---|
| Counted among them by 5 of our authors | Marc, Institutiones I, n. 91; Bucceroni, Commentarii, n. 108; Konings, Compendium, n. 79; Vermeersch, Theologia moralis I, n. 357; Tanquerey, Fundamental Moral Theology, n. 397 |
| “Lessius Leonardus, Belgian, is to be numbered among the greatest ornaments of the Society of Jesus, and we can scarcely suffice to praise him. From youthful age even to his end, always ill and broken by pains, he seemed to draw out life without flesh; wherefore it is to be wondered how he could write so much and excel so singularly in all doctrines, sacred and profane. The wisest men of his age, s”Haringer marks him **, giving St. Alphonsus's judgment of him (weighty and probabilist) | Haringer's index, Index of writers, p. XXII |
| “These agree in substantial matters with the equiprobabilists, and can be called moderate probabilists. Such are Suarez, Vasquez, Lugo, Lessius, Laymann, Sylvius, Palaus, Viva, Abelly, Reuter, Voit, etc.”Moderate probabilist. Marc calls him a moderate probabilist, agreeing in substance with the equiprobabilists, and will not attack him | Marc, Institutiones I, n. 86 |
| Charged with laxity | |
| “Chapter I — First, the condemned propositions are recounted; then those which seem lax … V. That women's cosmetics, and the exquisite adornments of face and head, hold a middle nature, removed both from honesty and from malice, Lessius writes, book 4 On justice, chapter 4, doubt 14, number 114.”Concina's censuses of lax opinions list 14 of his opinions and names him in 1 more as teaching or approving one (the first is quoted; every one is under 'Where Our Authors Discuss Him') | Concina, Compendium I, bk. III, diss. IV, ch. I, n. V |
Where Our Authors Discuss Him
Each read in its full passage; the words quoted are the author's own. Where several authors say the same thing, one is quoted and the others follow “in nearly the same words”; point at a name to see his words.
| “Thus L. Molina, On Justice and Law; Lessius, S.J. (1623), On the Four Cardinal Virtues; D. Soto, O.Pr. (1560), On Justice and Law”His De iustitia et iure and other works on the virtues | Vermeersch, Theologia moralis I, n. 19In nearly the same words: Tanquerey, Fundamental Moral Theology, n. 47; Koch-Preuss, Handbook I, history of moral theology; Koch-Preuss, Handbook I, history of moral theology |
| “such as Suarez, Vasquez, Lessius, Lugo, Gregory of Valencia, Becanus”Marc, after Ernest Müller: among the celebrated scholastics and casuists | Marc, Institutiones I, n. 6In nearly the same words: Marc, Institutiones I, n. 6 |
| “The classical theologians of the Society of Jesus, such as Molina, Lessius, and Cardinal de Lugo”Vermeersch names him among the classical Jesuit theologians who assent to the scholastic doctrine of usury | Vermeersch, Quaestiones de iustitia, n. 360 |
| “Already Lessius, chap. 20, nos. 123-127, permitted any merchant”Vermeersch: he already allowed any merchant to charge for the burden of being without money for a time | Vermeersch, Quaestiones de iustitia, n. 360 |
| “hold plainly that it is de fide that usury is illicit”Vermeersch: he holds that the illicitness of usury is of faith, at least by positive law | Vermeersch, Quaestiones de iustitia, n. 362 |
| “Leonard Lessius, On Justice, Book II, chap. 14, doubt 8, no. 51: And although the evil work for which he gave is not appraisable at a price inasmuch as it is” | Concina, Compendium II, bk. IX, diss. I, ch. II, n. IV |
| “The same Lessius, in the place cited, no. 48: You will say: St. Augustine, Epistle 54 to Macedonius, says that it is more wicked to accept money for an unjust” | Concina, Compendium II, bk. IX, diss. I, ch. II, n. V |
| “Chapter II — The lax opinions of several Casuists … VI. Fr. Lessius, Book II, chap. 19, doubt 3, no. 21: “Thirdly, if an heir ab intestato should retain the inheritance and the legacies, those to whom something had been left by such a testament may use occult compensation: for in truth the thing was theirs.””Concina lists among the lax opinions of the casuists (on justice, restitution, occult compensation and usury) | Concina, Compendium II, bk. IX, diss. I, ch. II, n. VI |
| “Chapter II — The lax opinions of several Casuists … VIII. Fr. Lessius, in the place cited, no. 50: “Thirdly, the heir ab intestato may retain it; and if another possesses it, he may sue for it at law. Fourthly, that if he cannot do so because of the power of his adversary, he may use occult compensation.””Concina lists among the lax opinions of the casuists (on justice, restitution, occult compensation and usury) | Concina, Compendium II, bk. IX, diss. I, ch. II, n. VIII |
| “Chapter II — The lax opinions of several Casuists … XXIII. Lessius, cited in Matthew de Moya, Vol. I, Select Questions, tract 6, Miscellany, disputation 4, question 3: “When a servant asks nothing by way of wage — nay, expressly rejects in his heart every intention of asking — and serves in the hope that some office or benefice will be procured for him by his master: when the master has procured it for him, even if he has obtained nothing, he cannot ask for anything, nor compensate himself.”Concina lists among the lax opinions of the casuists (on justice, restitution, occult compensation and usury) | Concina, Compendium II, bk. IX, diss. I, ch. II, n. XXIII |
| “Chapter II — The lax opinions of several Casuists … XXIX. Fr. Leonard Lessius, Book II, chap. 2, doubt 22, no. 135: “If you have unjustly defamed another who had previously defamed you, you are not bound to restitution towards him, if he is unwilling to make restitution to you; but you may use compensation, equality nevertheless being preserved as far as may be.””Concina lists among the lax opinions of the casuists (on justice, restitution, occult compensation and usury) | Concina, Compendium II, bk. IX, diss. I, ch. II, n. XXIX |
| “Chapter II — The lax opinions of several Casuists … XXX. The same Lessius, in the place cited, no. 136, to the question whether defamation may be compensated by the occult retention or filching of money, answers: “It is probable that this compensation may be made: because that opinion is probable which asserts that defamation is to be compensated with money, when it is not restored in its own kind.””Concina lists among the lax opinions of the casuists (on justice, restitution, occult compensation and usury) | Concina, Compendium II, bk. IX, diss. I, ch. II, n. XXX |
| “Fr. Leonard Lessius, Book II, chap. 14, doubt 9, no. 64: If he (the judge) accept something, that he may follow this opinion rather than that in judging, he” | Concina, Compendium II, bk. IX, diss. I, ch. II, n. XXXVI |
| “Fr. Lessius, Book II, chap. 21, doubt 16, no. 131: Observe nevertheless that this manner of contracting is often not free from fault in a merchant who by” | Concina, Compendium II, bk. IX, diss. I, ch. II, n. XXXVIII |
| “Fr. Leonard Lessius, Book II, chap. 20, doubt 10, no. 74: Observe nevertheless that if in truth from a loan of a hundred gold pieces you are certainly about to” | Concina, Compendium II, bk. IX, diss. I, ch. II, n. XLVI |
| “The same Lessius, in the place cited, no. 90: The third mode is this. If I had destined money for trade, and they should ask a loan: concerning which mode” | Concina, Compendium II, bk. IX, diss. I, ch. II, n. XLVII |
| “Fr. Leonard Lessius, Book II, chap. 21, doubt 16, no. 130: Certain Doctors judge that it is unjust and palliated usury when the same man buys back who sold.” | Concina, Compendium II, bk. IX, diss. I, ch. II, n. LVIII |
| “Fr. Lessius, Book II, chap. 23, doubt 9, no. 85: You will ask whether that which is owed to exchangers by reason of provisions and interest may be continuously” | Concina, Compendium II, bk. IX, diss. I, ch. II, n. LX |
| “Chapter IV — Lax, or improbable, propositions are reviewed, which not a few Casuists teach … VII. "Merchants who cannot obtain a just price from buyers, unless they swear that their goods stand them at such-and-such a price, when in fact this is not so, can indeed swear that the goods stand them at such-and-such a price, understanding, with all expenses computed, or reckoning in the goods which they have at home, or which they bought elsewhere."”Concina names him in the same number as teaching or approving the lax opinion (on the oath) | Concina, Theologia V, diss. I, ch. IV, n. VII |
| “Likewise S. D. calls that doctrine lax which authors of the past century almost commonly handed down, namely in the latter part of that century, in which several lax opinions of probabilists were condemned by the Holy See; but certainly not Sanchez, Suarez, Lessius, Palaus, Laymann, Lugo, Pallavicini and very many others, whom S. Alph. himself, not only in his Moral Works, but in that very Dissertation on his moral system, approves and praises for his opinion.”Bucceroni: not among the authors St. Alphonsus called lax, but among those he approves and praises | Bucceroni, Institutiones, n. 133 |
| “The sentence of Lessius, that it is not illicit to advise a lesser evil to one prepared to inflict a graver one”Bucceroni: St. Alphonsus judged this opinion of Lessius more probable, then sufficiently probable, then not improbable | Bucceroni, Commentarii, n. 126 |
| “Now he is esteemed a great theologian who possesses the greatest authority among theologians on account of his distinguished doctrine, prudence, and probity”Konings names him among the great theologians whose word that an opinion is probable makes it so | Konings, Compendium, n. 57 |
In the Catholic Encyclopedia (1913)
“Leonard Lessius”, vol. 9, by Joseph de Ghellinck. Public domain; transcription from Wikisource.
(LEYS)
A Flemish Jesuit and a theologian of high reputation, born at Brecht, in the province of Antwerp, 1 October, 1554; died at Louvain, 15 January, 1623. His parents, honest people of the farming class, died when he was but six years old. In 1568 he entered the college of Arras in the University of Louvain, and there studied classics and philosophy. His brilliant talents enabled him to become doctor in philosophy at the age of seventeen years; and although he did not learn Greek till later, he mastered it so well that he could mentally translate into that language the reading he heard in the refectory, and sometimes wrote his private notes in Greek. Professors vied with one another in seeking to have him as their pupil. In 1572, and not, as the date is sometimes given, in 1573, he entered the Society of Jesus, and after two years' noviceship was sent to Douai to teach philosophy in the Jesuit College there till 1581. He studied theology in Rome, where he had Francis Suarez as his professor for two years. In 1585 he was back again at Louvain as professor of theology in the Jesuit College and held this chair for fifteen years. When he had given up teaching, he was urged by his superiors and companions to publish the lectures on theology which he had delivered with such great success; this he did, yielding at last to their wishes. He was twice sent to Rome by the members of the Gallo-Belgian province to the general congregations of his order in 1608 and 1615. Cardinal Bellarmine and other dignitaries of the Church endeavoured, though unsuccessfully, to retain him in Rome and to attach him to the Sacred Penitentiary. He was consulted from all quarters, and corresponded on theological matters with the most learned doctors of the day, such as Bellarmine, Suarez, Vasquez, Molina, etc. But he longed to have done with studying and writing books, that he might turn to prayer and contemplation towards the end of his career. His remains are in the choir of the Jesuit church in Louvain. Leonard Lessius was a man of great virtue and of great science; his modesty and humility were equal to his learning, nor did he ever hesitate to give up his own opinion when good arguments against it were presented to him; his charity, meekness, patience, and mortification were remarkable throughout his long life, in spite of the trying disease he contracted when fleeing from Douai to escape the Calvinists. Pope Urban VIII, who had known him personally, paid a special tribute to his sanctity; St. Francis of Sales also esteemed him highly for his virtue and his science. After his death, authentic information was taken about his life and virtues; he is now ranked among the venerable, and the process of his beatification has been introduced.
The literary activity of Lessius was not confined to dogmatic and moral matters; he wrote also on asceticism and controversy. We give here the most important of his works; the whole list may be seen in Sommervogel. The first printed lines which came from the pen of Lessius, i. e. "Theses theologicæ" (Louvain, 1586), provoked a fiery debate with the doctors of the University of Louvain; the theses of Lessius and Hamelius, both professors at the Jesuit College, were attacked as containing dangerous opinions on predestination, grace, inspiration in Holy Scripture, etc. As to the last point, Lessius had merely suggested an hypothesis on subsequent inspiration, i. e. that a book written without the help of the Holy Ghost might become Holy Scripture, if the Holy Ghost apparently declared that the said book did not contain anything false. The condemnations issued by the Vatican Council did not touch this view of Lessius. The doctrine of Lessius on grace and predestination, which was accused of Semipelagianism, taught predestination "post prævisa merita", the co-operation of free will with grace in such a way as to reject the "gratia per se efficax"; in fact, this doctrine was by no means peculiar to Lessius. Apologies, antitheses, anti-apologies, succeeded on both sides; the Universities of Louvain and Douai censured the theses; the faculties of theology of Ingolstadt, Mainz, and Trier approved them; the general of the Jesuits and at last the pope was appealed to. Finally Sixtus V, who in a letter called the incriminated articles "articuli sanæ doctrinæ", charged his nuncio at Cologne, Octavio Frangipani, to bring the discussions to an end till the pope should have decided the question; Frangipani (1588) forbade both sides, under threat of excommunication, to discuss the matter or to charge each other with heresy.
The great work of Lessius is "De justitia et jure", which was published in 1605 and was dedicated to the Archduke Albert. Many editions followed at Antwerp, Louvain, Lyons, Paris, and Venice. This work, composed with great accuracy, shows best the soundness of judgment, the common sense, and the clearness of mind which distinguishes Lessius. The chapters on interest and other commercial subjects are epoch-making in the treatment of those difficult questions; Lessius was especially consulted by the merchants of Antwerp on matters of justice. Archduke Albert had the book constantly on his desk and referred to it as a guide. A good compendium of the work was published at Douai in 1634. Four years later a work of quite a different nature was written by Lessius under the title, "Quæ fides et religio sit capessenda" (Antwerp, 1609). It is a short book of some 150 pages, on controversy and apologetics, which brought about a great many conversions, among them that of John of Nassau. The book was often reprinted and was translated into Flemish, German, Italian, Hungarian, Polish, and French. The work "De gratia efficaci", on grace, liberty, predestination, etc., appeared in 1610; with the "De justitia" it secures Lessius a place among the best theologians of the day in dogmatic as well as in moral questions. Some writings of a controversial character were published between 1611 and 1619; "De Antichristo et ejus præcursoribus"; "Defensio potestatis summi pontificis", against the theories put forward by James I, King of England, Barclay, Blackwell, etc. A work on Providence and the immortality of the soul was printed in 1613 "De Providentia Numinis", and translated into different languages, even into Chinese. His "Hygiasticon" or plea for sobriety, a treatise on how to preserve strength and to live long, was published in 1613, often reprinted and translated into nearly all the languages of Europe; it is a translation of a similar work by Cornaro (Luigi Cornaro, an Italian hygienist, 1467-1566), accompanied with the personal reflections of Lessius. Even now it is not without interest.
Among his ascetical works, which are noted for the science and piety they contain, must be mentioned his "De summo bono" (Antwerp, 1616); "De perfectionibus moribusque divinis libri XIV" (Antwerp, 1620); and especially his posthumous work, on the Divine names, "Quinquaginta nomina Dei" (Brussels, 1640), very often reprinted and translated. After his death was published his theological treatise on the sacraments, the Incarnation, etc. (De beatitudine, de actibus humanis, de incarnatione Verbi, de sacramentis et censuris, etc., Louvain, 1645). Not a few of his unprinted works are preserved at Brussels and elsewhere; they are made up especially of theological treatises, notes on morals, some letters and documents on the discussion mentioned above, answers to various consultations, etc. No complete edition of Lessius's works has ever appeared. The books "De perfectionibus divinis", "De gratia efficaci", "De summo bono", etc. were published in Paris (1878-81); "De divinis nominibus" and "De summo bono" at Freiburg (1862 and 1869); Bouix made a new French translation of the "De divinis nominibus" (Paris, 1882).
DE RAM, Vie et Ecrits de L. Lessius in Revue Catholique, XIX (1861), 189; DE BLOCK, Le Père Lessius in Précis Historiques, XII (1863), 133, 188, 210; HURTER, Nomenclator; SCHOOFS, De Vita et Moribus L. Lessii (Brussels, 1640); SOMMERVOGEL, Bibl. de la Comp. de Jésus, IV (Brussels, 1893), 1726. Bibliographie Nationale, XII, 79; IV, 774; WERNER, Der hl. Thomas von Aquino, III (Ratisbon, 1859), 382.
J. de Ghellinck