Treatise — Merkelbach, Summa Theologiae Moralis
Treatise: On Sins in General
Introduction
410. Object of the treatise. - Moral theology treats of human acts by which we come to the end, beatitude. They are those acts which are conformed to the dictate of right conscience and to the eternal law. But there are also human acts which are not conformed to the law of God or to the dictate of right conscience, by which we do not come to the end, and which are called sins. Hence, after the treatises on the end, on human acts, and on their rules, namely, on conscience and on law, the consideration of evil acts or sins rightly follows.
411. The treatise is divided into three parts:
The first part treats of sin according to itself:
- of the essence of sin; 2) of the distinction of sins, a) specific, b) numerical; 3) of the comparison and gravity of sins; 4) of the subject of sin, where internal sins are treated.
The second part treats of the causes of sins:
- of interior causes: a) of ignorance on the part of reason, b) of passion on the part of the sensitive appetite, c) of malice on the part of the will;
- of exterior causes: a) of God permitting, b) of the devil tempting, c) of man cooperating;
- of sin which is the cause of another sin, namely, of the mode by which one sin causes another, and of capital sins.
The third part treats of the effects of sin:
- of the diminution of the good of nature; 2) of stain or guilt of fault; 3) of guilt of punishment; 4) of mortal and venial sin, which are distinguished according to diverse effects: a) of the distinction of mortal sin from venial, b) of its gravity, c) of the conditions required for it, d) of the division of mortal and venial sins, e) of their conversion, f) of venial sin according to itself.
412. Importance of the treatise. - The treatise is of the greatest importance, because it applies the abstract general principles concerning human acts more determinately and concretely to sins, which above all are to be avoided by each one, and are to be estimated and judged in others by the priest and confessor.
- The following can usefully be consulted: St. Thomas, Quaestiones Disputatae de Malo 1, 2, 3, 7; and I-II, q. 71-89 with the commentaries of Cajetan and Billuart; St. Alphonsus, Theologia Moralis, book V; Reiffenstuel, Theologia Moralis; Ferraris, Prompta Bibliotheca; Ballerini-Palmieri, Opus theologicum morale, vol. I; Billot, De peccato personali et originali; Theologia Mechliniensis, Tractatus de Peccatis, edited by St. Carton de Wiart; Lumbreras, De Vitiis et Peccatis; Deman, article "Peche," in Dictionnaire de Theologie; and manuals known to all, such as Van der Velden, Haine, Aertnijs, Marc, Lehmkuhl, Genicot, Noldin, Tanquerey, Prummer, and Vermeersch.
Within this treatise
First Part: On Sin According to Itselfnn. 413–460
First Question: On the Essence of Sinnn. 413–431
- Article I: On the Notion and Conditions of Sinnn. 413–418
- Article II: On the Sin of Omission Negatively Voluntarynn. 419–421
- Article III: On the External Sin of Commission, Indirectly or in the Cause Voluntarynn. 422–424
- Article IV: On the Constitutive Elements of Sinnn. 425–427
- Article V: On the Definition of Sinnn. 428–431
Second Question: On the Distinction of Sinsnn. 432–440
- Article I: On Specific Distinctionnn. 432–436
- Article II: On Numerical Distinctionnn. 437–440
- Third Question: On the Comparison and Gravity of Sinsnn. 441–445
Second Part: On the Causes of Sinsnn. 461–514
First Question: On the Interior Causes of Sinnn. 461–477
- Article I: On Ignorance as a Cause of Sin on the Part of Reason — On Sins of Ignorancenn. 464–466
- Article II: On Passion as a Cause of Sin on the Part of the Sensitive Appetite — On Sins of Infirmitynn. 467–470
- Article III: On Malice as a Cause of Sin on the Part of the Will — On Sins of Malicenn. 471–477
Second Question: On the Exterior Causes of Sinsnn. 478–492
- Article I: On God Permittingnn. 479–480
- Article II: On the Devil Temptingnn. 481–486
- Article III: On Man Cooperatingnn. 487–492
Third Question: On Sin Which Is the Cause of Another Sinnn. 493–514
- Article I: On the Mode in Which One Sin Causes Anothernn. 493–498
- Article II: On Pride and Vainglorynn. 499–502
- Article III: On Avaricenn. 503–504
- Article IV: On Lust and Gluttonynn. 505–506
- Article V: On Envy and Angernn. 507–510
- Article VI: On Acediann. 511–514
Third Part: On the Effects of Sinsnn. 515–555
- First Question: On the Diminution of the Good of Naturenn. 515–516
- Second Question: On the Debt of Guilt or the Stain of Sinnn. 517–520
- Third Question: On the Debt of Punishmentnn. 521–529
Fourth Question: On Mortal and Venial Sinnn. 530–555
- Article I: On the Difference Between Mortal and Venial Sinnn. 530–533
- Article II: On the Gravity of Mortal Sinnn. 534–537
- Article III: On the Conditions Required for Mortal Sinnn. 538–542
- Article IV: On the Division of Mortal and Venial Sinnn. 543–546
- Article V: On the Conversion of Mortal and Venial Sinnn. 547–550
- Article VI: On Venial Sin in Itselfnn. 551–555