distinction — Decretum of Gratian
Distinction LXVI
GRATIAN. Part I. Archbishops, however, ought to be ordained by all the bishops of their province. Hence Pope Anicius says, [in the epistle to the Bishops of Gaul]:
GRATIANUS. I. Pars. Archiepiscopi autem ab omnibus suae prouincia episcopis debent ordinari. Unde Anicius Papa ait: [in epist. ad Episcopos Galliae]
Friedberg, col. 251/252
C. I. An archbishop is to be ordained by all the suffragan bishops.
Let an archbishop be ordained by all the bishops of his province. § 1. What has been commanded concerning the consecration of an archbishop—that all the suffragans ordain him—may in no way be changed, because the one who presides over all the bishops over whom he presides ought to be constituted by them all. But if it has been presumed otherwise, there is no doubt that it lacks force, because the ordination transacted otherwise will be void. Part II. GRATIAN. Concerning bishops not to be ordained by fewer than three bishops, Anacletus writes, [epistle II to the Bishops of Italy], saying:
C. I. Ab omnibus suffraganeis episcopis archiepiscopus ordinetur.
Archiepiscopus ab omnibus suae prouinciae episcopis ordinetur. §. 1. Hoc autem, quod de archiepiscopi consecratione preceptum est, ut omnes suffraganei eum ordinent, nullatenus licet inmutari, quia ille qui preest ab omnibus episcopis, quibus preest debet constitui. Sin autem aliter presumptum fuerit, uiribus carere non dubium est, quia irrita erit secus acta ordinatio. II. Pars. Gratian. De episcopis non ordinandis a paucioribus quam a tribus episcopis, scribit Anacletus [ep. II. ad episcopos Italiae] dicens:
Friedberg, col. 251/252
[C. II.]
Moreover, Blessed James, the first archbishop of Jerusalem, who was called the Just and was named the Lord’s brother according to the flesh, was ordained by the apostles Peter, James, and John; they plainly gave a form to their successors that in no way is a bishop to be ordained by fewer than three bishops, with all the others furnishing assent, and that the ordination is to be celebrated by a common vote.
[C. II.]
Porro et Ierosolimitarum primus archiepiscopus B. Iacobus, qui Iustus dicebatur, et secundum carnem Domini frater nuncupatus est, a Petro, Iacobo et Iohanne apostolis ordinatus est, successoribus uidelicet dantibus formam eorum, ut minus quam a tribus episcopis, reliquisque omnibus assensum prebentibus, nullatenus episcopus ordinetur, et communi uoto ordinatio celebretur.
Friedberg, col. 253/254