distinction — Decretum of Gratian
Distinction LXXVII
GRATIAN. At these times, according to Anacletus, Zephyrinus, Gelasius, and Pelagius, bishops, priests, and deacons are to be ordained. According to Pope Leo, however, the best man among the priests or deacons of the same church is to be ordained metropolitan. But no one from among monks or laymen ought to arrive at the supreme priesthood except through the grades of the Church. Hence Pope Gelasius:
GRATIANUS. His temporibus secundum Anacletum, Zepherinum, Gelasium et Pelagium episcopi, presbiteri et diaconi sunt ordinandi. Metropolitanus autem iuxta Leonem papam ex presbiteris eiusdem ecclesiae uel ex diaconibus optimus ordinetur. Ex monachis autem uel laicis nullus nisi per gradus ecclesiae ad summum sacerdotium debet peruenire. Unde Gelasius Papa:
Friedberg, col. 271/272
C. I. No one is to aspire to the priesthood except through the distinct grades.
Enacting this, we command you and all to observe it: that those who deserve to be ordained are to approach ecclesiastical orders in the Church in this way; that is, if anyone deserves to be a bishop, let him first be a doorkeeper, then a reader, thereafter an exorcist, from there let him be consecrated an acolyte, and finally a subdeacon, then a deacon, and afterward a priest; from there, if he deserves it, let him be ordained bishop. Likewise Zosimus, Bishop of the city of Rome, says, [to Hesychius, epistle I, c. 3]:
C. I. Non nisi per distinctos gradus quisquam ad sacerdotium aspiret.
Illud nos statuentes uobis et omnibus seruare mandamus, ut ad ordines ecclesiasticos sic accedant in ecclesia, qui ordinari merentur: id est, si quis episcopus esse meretur, sit primo hostiarius, deinde lector preterea exorcista, inde sacretur acolitus, demum uero subdiaconus, deinde diaconus, et postea presbiter, exinde, si meretur, episcopus ordinetur. Item Zosimus Episcopus urbis Romae ait: [ad Hesychium, epist. I. cap. 3.]
Friedberg, col. 271/272
C. II. What intervals of time are to be observed in the individual grades.
In the individual grades these periods are to be observed if a man has given his name to ecclesiastical ministries from infancy: he is to be held among the readers and exorcists for five years; thereafter let him be made an acolyte or subdeacon for fourteen years, and thus, if he deserves it, let him approach the blessing of the diaconate, in which order he ought to adhere for five years if he has conducted himself blamelessly. Thereafter, with his years of service supporting him and proofs of his own faith having been given through so many grades, he will be able to merit the priesthood; from which place, if a more exacting life has led him to good conduct, he ought to hope for the supreme pontificate. § 1. Let the defenders of the Church also, who are made from laymen, be held to the aforesaid observance if they deserve to be in the clerical order.
C. II. Que interualla temporis in singulis gradibus sint obseruanda.
In singulis gradibus hec tempora sunt obseruanda, si ab infantia ecclesiasticis ministeriis nomen dederit, ut inter lectores et exorcistas quinquennio teneatur, exinde acolitus uel subdiaconus quatuordecim annis fiat, et sic ad benedictionem diaconatus, si meretur, accedat, in quo ordine quinque annis, si inculpate gesserit, adherere debebit. Exinde suffragantibus stipendiis, per tot gradus datis propriae fidei documentis, sacerdotium poterit promereri, de quo loco, si eum exactior uita ad bonos mores perduxerit, summum pontificatum sperare debebit. §. 1. Defensores etiam ecclesiae, qui ex laicis fiunt, supradicta obseruatione teneantur, si meruerint in ordine esse clericatus.
Friedberg, col. 271/272
C. III. On the same.
Likewise Pope Siricius, [to Himerius of Tarragona, epistle I, c. 9]. Whoever therefore has devoted himself to the services of the Church from his infancy ought to be baptized before the years of puberty and joined to the ministry of the readers. If from the beginning of adolescence until the thirtieth year of age he has lived commendably, content with only one wife—and she a virgin whom he received with the common blessing through the priest—he ought to be an acolyte and subdeacon, after which let him approach the grade of the diaconate if he has first proved himself worthy, with continence going before. There, if he has ministered laudably for more than five years, let him fittingly obtain the presbyterate. Thereafter, after ten years, he will be able to attain the episcopal chair, provided nevertheless that through these periods the integrity of his life and faith has been approved. But one who, already advanced in age, is stirred by the manner of life of a better purpose and hastens to pass from the lay state to the sacred soldiery will obtain the fruit of his desire in no other way than if, at the time when he is baptized, he is immediately joined to the number of readers or exorcists, provided nevertheless that it is established that he has had or has one wife and received her as a virgin. When he has been initiated, after two years have been completed, let him be made an acolyte and subdeacon for another five years, and thus let him be promoted to the diaconate if through these periods he has been judged worthy. Thereafter, with the passage of the required periods, let him not undeservedly be joined to the presbyterate or episcopate if the election of the people and clergy has summoned him.
C. III. De eodem.
Item Siricius Papa. [ad Himerium Tarraconensem, epist. I. cap. 9.] Quicumque itaque se ecclesiae uouit obsequiis a sua infantia, ante pubertatis annos baptizari et lectorum debet ministerio sociari; qui ab accessu adolescentiae usque ad trigesimum etatis annum si probabiliter uixerit, una tantum, et ea, quam uirginem communi per sacerdotem benedictione percepit, uxore contentus, acolitus et subdiaconus esse debebit, postquam ad diaconii gradum (si se ipsum primitus, continentia preeunte, dignum probauerit) accedat. Ubi si ultra quinque annos laudabiliter ministrauerit, congrue presbiteratum consequatur. Exinde post decennium episcopalem cathedram poterit adipisci, si tamen per hec tempora integritas suae uitae ac fidei eius fuerit approbata. Qui uero iam etate grandeuus, melioris propositi conuersatione prouocatus, ex laico ad sacram miliciam peruenire festinat, desiderii sui fructum non aliter obtinebit, nisi eo quo baptizatur tempore statim lectorum aut exorcistarum numero societur, si tamen eum unam habuisse uel habere, et hanc uirginem accepisse constet uxorem. Qui, dum initiatus fuerit, expleto biennio, per quinquennium aliud acolitus et subdiaconus fiat, et sic ad diaconatum, si per hec tempora dignus iudicatus fuerit, prouehatur. Exinde iam accessu temporum presbiterio uel episcopatui, si eum plebis ac cleri euocauerit electio, non inmerito societur.
Friedberg, col. 271/272
C. IV. On the same.
Likewise from the Sixth Synod, [c. 15]. Let a subdeacon be ordained at no less than twenty years of age. § 1. But if anyone has been ordained in some priestly order outside the established periods, let him be deposed.
C. IV. De eodem.
Item ex Sexta Sinodo. [c. 15.] Subdiaconus non minor uiginti annorum ordinetur. §. 1. Si quis uero in aliquo ordine sacerdotali preter constituta tempora ordinatus fuerit, deponatur.
Friedberg, col. 273/274
C. V. On the same.
Likewise from the Third Council of Carthage, [c. 4]. It has pleased us that deacons are not to be ordained, nor virgins consecrated, before twenty-five years of age, and that readers are not to salute the people.
C. V. De eodem.
Item ex Concilio Cartaginensi III. [c. 4.] Placuit, ut ante uiginti quinque annos etatis nec diaconi ordinentur, nec uirgines consecrentur, et ut lectores populum non salutent.
Friedberg, col. 273/274
C. VI. The Levitical blessing is not to be furnished to those younger than twenty-five years.
Likewise from the Council of Agde, [cc. 16 and 17]. Let a bishop by no means entrust the blessing of the diaconate to persons younger than twenty-five years. § 1. Certainly, if married young men have consented to be ordained, the will of their wives is also to be sought in such a way that, with the sleeping chamber of the dwelling set apart and religious life promised, they may be ordained after they have together been converted. § 2. But let no metropolitan presume to ordain a priest or bishop before thirty years, that is, before he reaches the age of a perfect man, lest through his age—as sometimes happens—he be blamed for some error.
C. VI. Minoribus XXV. annis leuitica non prestetur benedictio.
Item ex Concilio Agatensi. [c. 16. et 17.] Episcopus benedictionem diaconatus minoribus quam uiginti quinque annorum penitus non committat. §. 1. Sane si coniugati iuuenes consenserint ordinari, etiam uxorum uoluntas ita requirenda est, ut sequestrato mansionis cubiculo, religione promissa, posteaquam pariter conuersi fuerint, ordinentur. §. 2. Presbiterum uero uel episcopum ante triginta annos, id est antequam ad uiri perfecti etatem perueniat, nullus metropolitanorum ordinare presumat, ne per etatem (quod aliquociens euenit) aliquo errore culpetur.
Friedberg, col. 273/274
C. VII. On the same.
Likewise from the Fourth Council of Toledo, [c. 20]. In the old law the Levites are commanded to serve the tabernacle from the twenty-fifth year, whose authority the holy Fathers also followed in the canons. Forgetful both of divine law and of the precepts of the canons, we make infants and boys Levites before the lawful age or experience of life. And therefore both divine law and the canonical judgments admonish us that this is not to be done by us any longer, but that Levites be consecrated from their twenty-fifth year of age and priests ordained from their thirtieth.
C. VII. De eodem.
Item ex Concilio Toletano IV. [c. 20.] In ueteri lege ab anno uicesimo et quinto Leuitae tabernaculo seruire iubentur, cuius auctoritatem in canonibus et sancti Patres secuti sunt. Nos et diuinae legis, et praeceptorum canonum inmemores, infantes et pueros Leuitas facimus ante legitimam etatem, aut experientiam uitae; ideoque ne ulterius fiat a nobis, et diuina lege, et canonicis ammonemur sententiis, sed a uicesimo quinto anno etatis suae Leuitae consecrentur, et a tricesimo presbiteri ordinentur.
Friedberg, col. 273/274
C. VIII. Through what intervals of time one who is elected from among monks into the clerical state is to be ordained.
Likewise Gelasius, [Pope, to the Bishops throughout Lucania, epistle I, c. 3]. If anyone instructed in a religious purpose and monastic disciplines approaches the clerical office, first let his past life be investigated: whether he is proved to be stained by no grave crime, whether perhaps he has not had a second wife, and whether he is shown not to have taken a woman rejected by her husband.
C. VIII. Per que interualla temporum ordinetur qui de monachis in clericatum eligitur.
Item Gelasius. [Papa ad Episcopos per Lucaniam, epist. I. cap. 3.] Si quis de religioso proposito et disciplinis monasterialibus eruditus ad clericale munus accedit, inprimis eius uita acta inquiratur, si nullo graui facinore probatur infectus; si secundam fortasse non habuerit uxorem, nec a marito reiectam sortitus ostenditur.
Friedberg, col. 273/274
[C. IX.]
The same, [in the same and the following chapter]. Let a novice monk supported by uprightness of conduct be made immediately a reader, notary, or certainly a defender; after three months let him be an acolyte, especially if age also supports him in this. In the sixth month let him receive the name of subdeacon, and, if he is of modest manner of life and upright will, in the ninth month let him be a deacon, and when the year has been completed let him be a priest; for the devotion of a holy purpose voluntarily undertaken is shown to have furnished him what the intervals of years would have conferred. § 1. But if any layman is to be aggregated to ecclesiastical offices, it is fitting to examine a person of this kind in each of the matters comprehended above so much more carefully as it is established that there is a difference between worldly and religious life, because ecclesiastical ministries are in any event to be assigned to suitable persons, not thrust upon unsuitable merits. And what can be fit for sacred services is to be sought in their qualities so much more as time is cut away from the period within which they would be attained, so that uprightness of conduct may be shown to possess what a more extended course of practice has not conferred, lest through the occasion of supplying a scarcity of clergy we be reckoned to have introduced vices into divine worship rather than to have procured lawful advantages for the Lord’s household. For their promotions we nevertheless add six months beyond the limits of a year, since, as has been said, a distinction ought to exist between a person devoted to divine worship and one coming from the manner of life of laymen. Yet we believe these things are to be indulged only to such an extent that, when this occasion has ceased for the churches, the ancient form of the paternal canons is preserved.
[C. IX.]
Idem. [eodem capite et sequenti] Monachus uero nouitius morum honestate fulcitus, continuo lector, uel notarius, aut certe defensor effectus, post tres menses existat acolitus, maxime si huic etiam etas suffragatur; sexto mense subdiaconi nomen accipiat, ac si modeste conuersationis honestaeque uoluntatis existat, nono mense diaconus, conpletoque anno sit presbiter; cui tamen, quod annorum fuerant interstitia collatura, sancti propositi sponte suscepta docetur prestitisse deuotio. §. 1. Si uero laicus quispiam ecclesiasticis est aggregandus offitiis, tanto sollicitius in singulis, que superius conprehensa sunt, huiusmodi decet examinare personam, quantum inter mundanam religiosamque uitam esse constat discriminis, quia utique conuenientia ecclesiae ministeria deputanda sunt, non inconuenientibus meritis ingerenda, tantoque magis quod sacris aptum possit esse seruitiis in eorum querendum est institutis, quantum de tempore, quo fuerint assequenda, decerpitur, ut morum hoc habere doceatur probitas, quod prolixior consuetudo non contulit, ne per occasionem supplendae penuriae clericatus uitia potius diuinis cultibus intulisse, non legitimae familiae Domini conputemur procurasse conpendia. Quorum promotionibus super anni metas sex menses nichilominus subrogamus, quoniam, sicut dictum est, distare debet inter personam diuino cultui deditam, et de laicorum conuersatione uenientem. Que tamen eatenus indulgenda credimus ut ecclesiis ab hac occasione cessantibus canonum paternorum uetus forma seruetur.
Friedberg, col. 273/274