Doubt — Bontempi, Palladium Theologicum V · from Schola Thomistica
Doubt VII: When things acquired by the use of common things are to be restored
IT happens not infrequently that wood is cut from the Community's Forests, and animals graze in its meadows.
Quando restituenda sint, quae sunt acquisita per usum rerum communium.
SOlent nonnunquam e Sylvis Communitatis ligna caedi, et animalia in pratis ipsius pasci.
IT IS ANSWERED that he is held to restitution of what he takes immoderately beyond what is licit to anyone as a member of the community. So Valencia quaest. 6. punct. 5. Except, if he is as it were in extreme need; for then he can even take what is necessary from the Forests of anyone whatsoever, as Sotus teaches lib. 4. de Iust. quaest. 6. art. 4. Medina quaest. 12. de restit. Valencia loc. cit. Tannerus num. 348. Molina Tom. 1. tract. 2. disp. 58. Salon. quaest. 62. art. 3. controu. 2.
RESPONDE TUR, teneri ad restitutionem eius, quod immoderate super id, quod alicui licet, ut membro communitatis. Ita Valentia quaest. 6. punct. 5. Excipe, si quasi extreme indigeat; tunc enim etiam de Sylvis quorumlibet potest necessarium accipere, ut docent Sotus lib. 4. de Iust. quaest. 6. art. 4. Medina quaest. 12. de restit. Valentia loc. cit. Tannerus num. 348. Molina Tom. 1. tract. 2. disp. 58. Salon. quaest. 62. art. 3. controu. 2.