Question — Bontempi, Palladium Theologicum V · from Schola Thomistica
Question X: Whether faith has grown as regards its light
I assert that Faith has grown in light from the beginning of the world.
Utrum FIDES creverit quoad lumen.
Assero, Fidem secundum lumen crevisse ab initio mundi.
It is PROVED first by the Seraphic Doctor from D. Gregor. homily 16. on Ezech., where, expounding that of Luke 10. Blessed are the eyes that see the things which you see, he says: With the increases of the times the knowledge of the Saints, and of the spiritual Fathers, grew. And the nearer they stood to the coming of the Savior, the more fully they perceived the mystery of salvation: Therefore they knew with a fuller light; but not except by the light of faith: Therefore. D. Thom. means the same, question 1. art. 4. to 4.: those nearer, namely to Christ, were suffused with a greater light — not all, indeed, but some. Valencia adds another limitation, that this is true of the infused light; for by natural light Theologians now know more things. But we were already speaking of the infused light of Faith.
Probatur primo a S. Doct. ex D. Gregor. homil. 16. in Ezech. ubi exponens id Lucae 10. Beati oculi, qui vident, quae vos videtis, ait: Secundum incrementa temporum crevit scientia Sanctorum, et spiritualium Patrum. Et quanto adventui Salvatoris viciniores extiterunt, tanto mysterium salutis plenius perceperunt: Ergo pleniori lumine cognoverunt; sed non nisi lumine fidei: Ergo. Idem sentit D. Thom. quaest. 1. art. 4. ad 4. viciniores, nempe Christo, maiori lumine fuisse perfusos, non omnes sane, sed aliquos. Addit Valentia aliam limitationem, hoc verum esse de lumine infuso; nam lumine naturali nunc iam Theologi plura cognoscunt. Sed iam nos loquebamur de lumine infuso Fidei.
Tanner adds, disp. 1. question 1. number 206., that not even one of the Doctors, succeeding in the Church, received the mysteries of faith more explicitly than the Apostles.
Addit Tanner. disp. 1. quaest. 1. num. 206. nullum etiam e Doctoribus, succedentibus in Ecclesia, explicatius Apostolis mysteria fidei accepisse.
But this is truly PROVED. John 14. The Paraclete will teach you all things; and chapter 15. All things that I have heard from the Father, I have made known to you. And chapter 16. When the Paraclete shall come, he will teach you all things, and at the end of Luke: Then he opened their sense, that they might understand the Scriptures, as the Seraphic Doctor observes in his commentaries. And 2 Corinth. 3. Beholding with unveiled face the glory of the Lord. The Seraphic Doctor adds that of Acts 2., where Peter admonishes the Jews, the prophecy of Joel, chapter 2., being now fulfilled: And it shall be in the last days I will pour out of my spirit upon all flesh, and they shall prophesy, and shall see visions.
PROBATUR vero hoc. Ioan. 14. Paracletus vos docebit omnia; et cap. 15. Omnia, quae audivi a Patre, nota feci vobis. Et cap. 16. Cum venerit Paracletus, ille vos docebit omnia, et Lucae ultimo: Tunc aperuit illis sensum, ut intelligerent Scripturas, ut observat S. Doct. in commentariis. Et secunda Corinth. 3. Nos revelata facie gloriam Domini speculantes. Addit S. Doct. illud Act. 2. ubi Petrus admonet Iudaeos, iam impleti Ioëlis prophetiam capite 2. Et erit in novissimis diebus effundam de spiritu meo super omnem carnem, et prophetabunt, et visiones videbunt.
The Seraphic Doctor adds, to those words at the end of Luke, an argument from the Scriptures; For Christ has the key of knowledge, as is said Isa. 22. and Apoc. 5. The Lamb opened the Book of revelations, hidden before, and the four animals, which accompany the Evangelists, and the twenty-four elders standing about, saw the secrets. Therefore, the nearer the disciples were to Christ, the wiser they were.
Addit S. Doct. ad ea verba Lucae ultimo, argumentum e Scripturis; Nam Christus habet clavem scientiae, ut dicitur Isa. 22. et Apoc. 5. Agnus aperuit Librum revelationum, antea occultatum, et quatuor animalia, quae Evangelistas comitantur, et vigintiquatuor seniores circumstantes viderunt arcana. Igitur, quo viciniores fuere discipuli Christo; eo sapientiores.
But D. Bonan. on chapter 16. of John objects. How does he say, chapter 15. I have made all things known to you, when here he says: I have many things to say to you? He answers with D. August. Tract. 96. that he speaks of those things that were revealed at the coming of the Holy Spirit, to which they were not yet disposed. For all things, written with canonical authority before the coming of the spirit (says St. Augustine), who hears, or reads? And he puts the past for the future; and signifies, I have made known, that is, I shall make known so certainly that you may hold them as things possessed.
Obiicit vero sibi D. Bonan. ad cap. 16. Ioan. Quomodo ait, cap. 15. Omnia nota feci vobis, at hic ait: Multa habeo vobis dicere? Respondet cum D. August. Tract. 96. eum loqui de his, quae revelata sunt in adventu Spiritus sancti, ad quae non erant adhuc dispositi. Omnia enim, Canonica (ait S. August) authoritate conscripta ante adventum spiritus, quis audit, vel legit? ponit autem praeteritum pro futuro; et significat, nota feci, idest, nota adeo certe faciam, ut ea possitis, ut habita, tenere.
But the Seraphic Doctor has most splendid things on this, sermon 9. on the day of Pentec., where he observes that the Apostles are called heavens formed by the Holy Spirit, Iob. 26. The spirit of the Lord adorned the heavens. Psal. 116. The heavens show forth the glory of God. Psal. 32. By the word of the Lord the heavens were made firm, and by the spirit of his mouth all their power, as the Fathers expound: and he joins this with that of John 16. When he, the Spirit of truth, shall come, he will teach you all truth, and says: As the heavens are, in which is the fountain of light, and the Luminaries, so in the Apostles shone forth the most splendid Lights of faith. And as in the foundations there is the greater substance, so in the Apostles, who are called the foundations of the Church, Ephes. 2. Apoc. 21. And as the Holy Spirit is called the Fount of the water leaping forth, poured out, which Christ was to give; so they who were nearer to this Fount drank in more: Therefore the holy Apostles were endowed with a greater Light of faith. By these arguments this is proved by the holy Fathers: Cyprian epistle 74. Ambrose sermon 24. Augustine book 5. on Baptism, against the Donatists, chapter 26., in Valencia. And Morand. question 5., who observes with Aragon here art. 7. Cardinal Lugo disp. 3. sect. 5., that the Apostles had explicit faith of all those things which the faithful are now bound to believe; But Suarez book 2. sect. 6. num. 18. holds that this is true only of things looking to the substance of those times, not of contingents, for instance, that the Council of Trent was lawfully convened, which nevertheless was then of faith, but only now declared; so assert Vualdens. book 2. of the doctrinal faith, chapter 22. Lyrin. against heresies chapter 17. Therefore, say Cano, Castr., and others, we are not to expect a new revelation unknown to the Apostles.
Praeclara vero habet de hoc S. Doct. serm. 9. in die Pentec. ubi observat, Apostolos vocari caelos a Spiritu Sancto formatos, Iob. 26. Spiritus Domini ornavit caelos. Psal. 116. caeli enarrant gloriam Dei. Psal. 32. Verbo Domini caeli firmati sunt, et spiritu oris eius omnis virtus eorum, ut Patres exponunt: haec autem componit cum illo Ioan. 16. Cum venerit ille Spiritus veritatis, docebit vos omnem veritatem, et ait: Sicut caeli sunt; in quibus est fons lucis, et Luminaria, ita in Apostolis splenduere Lumina fidei praeclarissima. Et sicuti in fundamentis est maior substantia, sic in Apostolis, qui dicuntur fundamenta Ecclesiae, Ephes. 2. Apoc. 21. Et sicut Spiritus Sanctus dicitur Fons aquae salientis effusus, quem Christus erat daturus; ita qui fuere viciniores huic Fonti, magis ebibere: Ergo Sancti Apostoli maiori Lumine fidei praediti sunt. His argumentis, hoc probant SS. PP. Cyprianus epist. 74. Ambros. serm. 24. August. lib. 5. de Baptismo, contra Donatistas, cap. 26. apud Valentiam. Et Morand. quaest. 5. qui observat cum Aragonio hic art. 7. Card. Lugo disp. 3. sect. 5. Apostolos habuisse fidem explicitam eorum omnium, quae nunc fideles tenentur credere; At Suarez lib. 2. sect. 6. num. 18. tenet, hoc verum solum de spectantibus ad substantiam illorum temporum, non de contingentibus, puta, quod fuerit Tridentinum legitime congregatum, quae tamen fuisse de fide etiam tunc, sed nunc solum declarata; asserunt Vualdens. lib. 2. doctrinalis fidei, cap. 22. Lyrin. contra haeres. cap. 17. Ideo inquiunt Cano, Castr. et alii, nobis non esse expectandam novam revelationem, Apostolis ignotam.
Indeed Peter doubted about this great point: Whether the Gospel was to be preached to the nations. Acts 10. and chapter 11.; he is in some way reproved by Paul concerning the use of legal observances.
Profecto Petrus dubitavit de hoc magno puncto: An Evangelium esset praedicandum gentibus. Act. 10. et cap. 11. aliquo modo reprehenditur circa usum legalium a Paulo.
The Seraphic Doctor goes on to prove the excellence of our faith in the Evangelical law above the Mosaic; because, as the prophecies were ever made clearer even in the old law — whence David says Psal. 118. I have understood above the ancients, and he was esteemed a prophet above the earlier ones; so likewise the later ones were irradiated by the new light, as it were, of the day of grace approaching; so up to the Gospel, in which is the perpetual, resplendent day, the faith is more resplendent. For the Gospel is Light; and the old Law is a Shadow; and so the interior illumination is more resplendent, and the exterior instruction, and therefore the faith is adorned with a greater light.
Pergit S. Doct. probare praecellentiam fidei nostrae in lege Evangelica supra Mosaicam; quia sicuti prophetiae semper fiebant clariores etiam in lege veteri; unde ait David Psal. 118. Super senes intellexi, et fuit aestimatus propheta, super antetiores; similiter et posteriores novo veluti diei gratiae advenientis lumine, fuere irradiati; sic usque ad Evangelium, in quo est dies perpetua praeclara, praeclarior est fides. Est enim Evangelium Lux; et Lex antiqua est Umbra; atque adeo praeclarior est illuminatio interior, et exterior instructio, ac proinde maiori lumine decoratur fides.
You will object first. What is above time is not increased by time. Such is faith: Therefore.
Obiicies primo. Quod est supra tempus, non augetur tempore. Talis est fides: Ergo.
The Seraphic Doctor answers that it is above time as to the moving reason, which is the first truth; but as to instruction it grew from night into day.
Respondet S. Doct. esse supra tempus, quoad rationem moventem, quae est prima veritas; at quoad instructionem crevit e nocte, in diem.
You will object second. That which shows a more hidden object is a more intense light; but the ancient faith showed the Redeemer to come, who was more hidden than now, since he has already come: Therefore.
Obiicies secundo. Id, quod ostendit occaltius obiectum, est lumen intensius; sed fides antiqua ostendebat Redemptorem futurum, qui erat magis occultus, quam nunc; cum iam advenerit: Ergo.
The Seraphic Doctor answers first that it would be truer, if such light showed the hidden thing more intensely, and more clearly, by revealing more of it: But if it reveals less, it is denied: Hence the light of faith, although it shows God hidden on the way, is less than the light of glory, which exhibits more, by making God, who is hidden from us, clearer. So the light of the old faith, showing Christ obscure, was more remiss, because it uncovered little of him, and less than ours.
Respondet S. Doct. primo, Maiorem esse veram, si tale lumen ostendat rem occultam intensius, et clarius, plus de ea patefaciendo: At si minus pandat, negatur: Hinc lumen fidei, etsi ostendat Deum in via occultum, est minus lumine gloriae, quod plus exhibet, reddendo Deum, qui nobis est occultus, clarius. Ita lumen veteris fidei, ostendens Christum obscurum, erat remissius, quia parum de eo detegebat, minusque nostro.
He answers second that the light which unfolds an object obscure in itself, and makes it appear clearer to the powers, is resplendent; But if it shows it in an obscuring cloud, it is not such. Now Christ was obscure in himself in ancient times; and as to the powers he was shown with little light, in shadowy manner; now, however, although he has already come, still objectively, in a natural way, he is little exhibited. For even if we know that there was in Judaea a famous man, called Jesus; and we read many things about him in the historians of the world; nevertheless we have received the knowledge of the Divine Person, of the truth of the doctrine, of the holiness, and of the miracles, by the light of faith, by which we believe the Gospels; and therefore the light that makes this hidden thing known to our minds is clearer than that light infused into the ancients. This reply contains, and explains the preceding one.
Respondet secundo, lumen, quod pandit obiectum in se obscurum, illudque potentiae facit clarius apparere, esse praeclarum; At si ostendat in nubilo, non est tale. Iam vero Christus erat antiquitus in se obscurus; et ex parte potentiarum parum lumine umbroso ostensus; nunc autem tametsi iam venerit, tamen obiective via naturali parum exhibetur. Esto enim sciamus, fuisse in Iudaea hominem celebrem, vocatum Iesum; multaque de eo apud historicos mundi legamus; attamen notitiam Personae Divinae, veritatis doctrinae, sanctitatis, et miraculorum, accepimus lumine fidei, quo Evangelia credimus; et ideo lumen, hoc occultum reddens mentibus notum, est clarius lumine illo, antiquis infuso. Haec responsio continet, et explicat praecedentem.
The same light suffused those who touched Jesus in the flesh; whence very many, although they saw the miracles, etc., did not believe, as D. Bonav. says, on 3.
Idem lumen perfudit eos, qui in carne Iesum contrectarunt; unde plurimi, tametsi viderint miracula, etc. non credidere, ut ait D. Bonav. ad 3.
You will object third. The light of faith that shows things to come is greater than that which shows things past: But the ancients saw things to come; We things past: Therefore.
Obiicies tertio. Maius est lumen fidei, quod ostendit futura, quam quod praeterita: Sed antiqui videbant futura; Nos praeterita: Ergo.
The Seraphic Doctor answers that things above natural cognition are equally obscure whether they be past, and that of such things there is prophecy. Thus Moses prophesied, describing the creation of the world Genes. 1., and other past things. And Elizabeth Luke 1. says: Blessed art thou that hast believed, and of such things is faith, as that Jesus the son of God died, etc., which are not accessible to natural light.
Respondet S. Doct. ea, quae sunt supra naturalem cognitionem, esse aeque obscura, si praeterita sint, et de talibus esse prophetiam. Sic prophetavit Moyses describens creationem mundi Genes. 1. et alia praeterita. Et Elisabeth Lucae 1. ait: Beata, quae credidisti, et de his est fides, ut quod Iesus filius Dei sit mortuus, etc. quae naturali lumini non sunt pervia.
You will object fourth. The illumination is greater where the communication of light is greater: But our faith is confirmed by the light even of the ancient Fathers: therefore it receives light from the ancients.
Obiicies quarto. Maior est illuminatio, ubi maior est luminis communicatio: Sed fides nostra confirmatur per lumen etiam antiquorum Patrum: ergo recipit ab antiquis lumen.
The Seraphic Doctor answers that this happens per accidens, insofar as those Fathers were set forth as lampstands for the posterity of the grace of the new law also. Thus the patience of Job, and of Tobias was set forth; the faith of Abraham, etc., that those first ones should be the exemplars of virtue, and that we, animated, might see what higher sanctity we are bound to climb in the testament of graces, to which indeed innumerable ones have flown over by the observance of the perfection of the counsels, although many have lain hidden under a bushel.
Respondet S. D. id evenire per accidens, quatenus expositi sunt Patres illi super candelabra posteris novae etiam legis gratiae. Sic exposita est Iobi, et Tobiae patientia; Abrahae fides, etc. ut illi primi essent Ideae virtutis, nosque animati videremus quam altiorem sanctitatem scandere teneamur in testamento gratiarum, ad quam sane innumeri supervolarunt consiliorum perfectionis observantia, etsi sub Modio latuerint multi.