Question — Bontempi, Palladium Theologicum V · from Schola Thomistica
Question IV: Whether religious ought, on account of poverty, to wear mean clothing
¶ I ASSERT that it is lawful to use a rough habit, nay, that it befits them. Thus St. Bonau. in cap. 2. Reg. et p. p. speculi discipl. ad novitios, cap. 25. This indeed contributes to poverty, humility, penance, and contempt of worldly things. Vuald. pursues these at length, lib. 3. doctr. fidei, cap. 27. Each orders obtains its own peculiar habit from the ancient custom and tradition of the Church, as is evident from St. Dionys. cap. 6. Eccl. Hier. from the Councils, Gangr. at the end, Aurel. V. cap. 19. Carth. IV. cap. 11. et 104. Tolet. VI. cap. 6. Tol. X. cap. 4. 5. 6. The Sixth General Synod, cap. 42. and excommunication is imposed upon one who rashly lays aside the habit, cap. es periculosa, tit. Ne Clerici, vel Monach. lib. 6. See Caiet. V. Excom. cap. 61. Valencia, d. 10. quaest. 5. puncto 4.
An Religiosi, ob Paupertatem, vilibus indui debeant.
¶ Assero, licere uti habitu rudi, imo id convenire. Ita D. Bonau. in cap. 2. Reg. et p. p. speculi discipl. ad novitios, cap. 25. Hoc sane ad paupertatem, humilitatem, poenitentiam, et rerum mundanarum contemptum confert. Haec late prosequitur Vuald. lib. 3. doctr. fidei, cap. 27. Habitum sane singuli ordines obtinent peculiarem ex antiqua Ecclesiae consuetudine, et traditione, ut constat e D. Dionys. cap. 6. Eccl. Hier. e Conciliis, Gangr. ad calcem, Aurel. V. cap. 19. Carth. IV. cap. 11. et 104. Tolet. VI. cap. 6. Tol. X. cap. 4. 5. 6. Sexta Synod. Gener. cap. 42. et imponitur excommunicatio temere habitum dimittenti, cap. es periculosa, tit. Ne Clerici, vel Monach. lib. 6. Vide Caiet. V. Excom. cap. 61. Valentiam d. 10. quaest. 5. puncto 4.
¶ I ASSERT that meanness of habit befits Religious.
¶ Assero, vilitatem habitus convenire Religiosis.
¶ It is proved by St. Bonaventure first: The habit indicates the state of the person, Eccli. 19. The apparel of a man declares him, but the Religious ought to be discerned from delicate seculars. Surely they who are clothed in soft garments are in the houses of kings, Matth. 11.
¶ Probatur a D. Bonavent. primo: Habitus indicat statum personae, Eccli. 19. Amictus hominis annunciat de eo, debet autem Religiosus discerni a saecularibus delicatis. Sane qui mollibus vestiuntur in domibus Regum sunt, Matth. 11.
LEARN THE COMPOSITION of the habit in the Seraphic Doctor.
COMPOSITIONEM habitus disce in S. Doctore.
FURTHERMORE he ENJOINS, that they not be stripped of the habit without necessity, even for a short time.
INIUNGIT porro, ne habitu absque necessitate, etiam ad modicum tempus exuantur.
IT IS FORBIDDEN under excommunication incurred ipso facto, to lay aside the habit rashly, cap. Ut periculosa, cit.
VETITUM est sub excommunicatione ipso facto, habitum deponere temere cap. Ut periculosa, cit.
NOTE that it is incurred through rashness, if it is laid aside without cause, and another is assumed unto apostasy, or he could be said to have laid it aside. See Politius in cap. 2. Reg. where he adds that excom. is not incurred by him who would strip himself in order to commit fornication, unless he put on another garment, that he might go unknown. Thus also Nauar. Man. cap. 27. num. 131. Sylvest. V. Excom. 9. num. 24. yet he would sin lethally. The habit ought to be worn openly abroad, from Trident. sess. 25. cap. 1. t. Rodrig. tom. 1. qq. quaest. 30. art. 2. It ought also to be worn at night, cap. Sanctimon. d. 23. See also Sanctem. ad cap. 2. Regulae.
ADVERTE eam incurri e temeritate, si absque causa deponitur, et alius assumitur ad apostasiam, vel possit dici deposuisse. Vide Politium in cap. 2. Reg. ubi addit non incurri excom. ab eo, qui ad fornicandum exueret, nisi alium indueret, ut abiret incognitus. Sic et Nauar. Man. cap. 27. num. 131. Sylvest. V. Excom. 9. num. 24. is tamen lethaliter peccaret. Debet habitus extra gestari patens, ex Trident. sess. 25. cap. 1. t. Rodrig. tom. 1. qq. quaest. 30. art. 2. Debet etiam nocte gestari cap. Sanctimon. d. 23. Vide et Sanctem. ad cap. 2. Regulae.
St. BONAVENTURA published another little work on sandals, in which he shows that these were worn from the times of the infant Church even by the very Apostles. Read him through.
D. BONAVENTURA opusculum aliud edidit de sandaliis, ubi ostendit, haec a temporibus nascentis Ecclesiae gestata fuisse etiam ab ipsis Apostolis. Eum perlege.